The Finsiders
The Finsiders Blog
Fantasy: Week 4 Lineup Advice
By on September 28, 2012 at 12:44 pm

Week 4 of the NFL season is here, and we all have fantasy teams ranging from 3-0 to 0-3, and every in between. While some may make most of their team upgrades via the waiver wire, you can also trade your way to fantasy domination. Our fantasy guru, James Morris, provides a glimpse into the mindset that you should take into fantasy trade negotiations while also providing his week 4 “start ’em & sit ’em” advice.

Q: I have been offered a trade I get Drew Brees, Stevan Ridley, C.J. Spiller and Victor Cruz, and I trade away Matt Ryan, LeSean McCoy, Mikel LeShoure, and Jordy Nelson. What are your thoughts? David “Date Doctor” Coleman.

A: Date Doctor, meet the Fantasy Weather Man. I’m all over the fantasy football knowledge like white on rice, on a paper plate, with a glass of milk, in a snow storm!

The answer is no. Let’s break this down mathematically: Brees = Ryan; Ridley < McCoy; Spiller < Leshore; Cruz = Nelson.

Cruz and Nelson are close in value, just as Brees and Ryan are close. I’d take McCoy and Leshoure over Ridley and Spiller any day of the week… and twice on Sunday!!! The guy is looking to dump Spiller because there is about to be a RBBC in Buffalo and Jackson is more than likely going to be in the driver’s seat. Ridley is a riddle, because the Patriots have never been one to use a RB well enough to provide consistent fantasy value.

You lose on both ends of the RB trade and break even on the QB and WR end. When looking at a trade, look at it player-for-player. If you lose on one side, fine. But, you have to make it up on the other side. And, the only time I take a 2-1 deal is if I have say an extra WR and he is giving me a RB and WR for bye-week depth. Most of the time in a 2-1 deal they are offering you two lesser players for your one stud, and you gain depth, but lose out on consistent points. If they offer a 3-1, block them from ever contacting you again! Don’t let their problems become YOUR problem.

Start ‘em

Cam Newton – QB Panthers: Cam I Am is sure to be looking to rebound from that embarrassment of a game he put in during week 3 (16-30 passing, 242 yards, no TDs and 3 INTs). The Falcons are ranked #7 against the pass, but they are #24 against the run. Newton can run as well as any QB in league history, so I am looking for a top 10 game from Newton this weekend.

Robert Griffin III – QB Redskins: There are two reasons why RGIII is going to be a beast this weekend: 1) The Buccaneers defense, and 2) The Redskins defense. The Bucs are dead last in the NFL against the pass (353.3 YPG allowed), and the Redskins are ranked 30th in overall defense (429.3 total YPG). The truth is the Buccs are susceptible to the pass, and the Redskins defense can’t keep the offense off the field long enough to not give RGIII every chance in the world to succeed.

Cedric Benson – RB Packers: The Saints are giving up an astonishing 215.0 YPG rushing and have allowed 6 rushing TDs, league highs in both. If there was ever a week for Benson to grab top 10 honors for fantasy RBs, this is the one. Benson is a shark, the Saints are the swimmers, and there is blood in the water!

BenJarvus Green-Ellis – RB Bengals: The Law Firm goes up against a Jaguars defense that is allowing 154.3 YPG on the ground, and they have allowed RBs to cross the goal line 5 times this season (2nd worst in NFL). BGE has scored two times so far, but has not hit 100-yards rushing in a game this season, and last week he put up an embarrassing 38 yards on the ground. I think the Bengals coaching staff will find a way to ground-and-pound BGE to 100 yards in this one.

Vincent Jackson – WR Buccaneers: Jackson is as inconsistent as they come (47, 128, and 29 yards receiving this season), but the Redskins pass defense is horrible and this could be a repeat of week 2 when he torched the Giants for 128 yards and a TD. I give him a low-end WR1/high-end WR2 ranking this weekend and think 100-yards and a TD are within reach.

Jeremy Maclin – WR Eagles: Maclin is allegedly healthy once again, and it couldn’t have come at a better time for the Eagles and Michael Vick. Maclin should be covered by Corey Webster and he has been struggling. I don’t think he is going to be a WR1, but 5-6 catches for 90 yards and a possible score I could see happening.

Kyle Rudolph – TE Vikings: The Detroit Lions are giving up the 2nd most fantasy points to TEs this season with 20.2 PPG. Rudolph has Ponder’s trust after he made a highlight reel grab for a TD last week, so I see no reason for the Vikings not to use their redzone target again this weekend. I have Rudolph as a TE1 this weekend, and so should you.

Seattle Seahawks defense: I got a friend, Alex Staats, and he is one of the biggest Seahawks fans I’ve ever met. So naturally I feel sorry for him most weeks. But, this week I have to jump on board the bandwagon and ride it until the wheels fall off! The Seahawks have a very good fantasy defense, and the Rams offense is… well… not very good at all. As I would say on Twitter, #GREATNESS!

Sit ‘em

Ryan Fitzpatrick – QB Bills: Fitzpatrick tossed 3 TDs last week and that caused him to jump up 7.5 percent in league to 22.5 percent. While that doesn’t sound like much, consider the sheer number of people that play fantasy football on, and how many “adds” it would take to move 7.5 percent.

Look, the real numbers you should be looking at is the 208 passing yards on 22-35 passing attempts against a Browns defense that is ranked 27th against the pass. This week he faces the Patriots and their 24th ranked pass defense. I think the Pats jump out ahead and he is forced to play catch-up, which in turn will force turnovers.

Jay Cutler – QB Bears: Chris Da Bears Fan isn’t going to like this, but Cutler and the Bears face the Dallas Cowboys and their 2nd ranked pass defense this week. In two of his first three games, Cutler has failed to reach 200 yards passing, a stat almost unheard of for a QB in the NFL. I would much rather sit Cutler and miss on a possible good game, and take a chance on someone like Christian Ponder who is owned in just 8.3 percent of leagues, and currently ranked #11 for QBs!

Chris Johnson – RB Titans: My colleague, Jon Cope, is still a believer in CJ2K, but I have abandoned ship from the RB Titanic known as Johnson. The Texans haven’t allowed a rushing TD yet this season, and are giving up just 67.7 YPG on the ground. That equates to just 3.8 YPC, and Johnson is only able to manage 1.4 YPC behind the Titans “O-Lay” blocking scheme. We will either see Johnson do the impossible (unlikely), or prove me correct in my assertion that he isn’t even worth owning at this point; my money is on the latter of the two.

Steven Jackson – RB Rams: Did you know S-Jax is owned in 97.5 percent of leagues, started in 60.3 percent of those leagues, but is ranked #35 for RBs? There are a LOT of FAs with better production than him on the waiver wire right now, so why do you continue to trot him out there for your fantast squad week in and week out? The guy is like the Willie Mays of the Mets for the NFL, just wondering around lost in an anemic Rams offense. If you won’t cut him, please stop starting him!

Jerome Simpson – WR Vikings: Simpson is back from suspension and the Vikings plan on throwing him right into the mix. The problem I have is possible rust and how many targets will he see with Percy Harvin and Kyle Rudolph already in Ponder’s good graces. I would rather sit him down than roll the dice on him in his first game this season.

Danny Amendola – WR Rams: Amendola exploded onto the scene for many fantasy players after he hauled in 15 passes for 160 yards and a TD in week 2. That has vaulted him to being owned in 71.6 percent of leagues, and started 35.4 percent of those leagues. The problem this week is he faces an underrated Seahawks defense (#10 in receiving yards allowed with 229.7 YPG and just 2 TDs allowed) that is still riding high after Golden Tate scored a last second touchdown by catching the man (M.D. Jennings) who caught the ball!

Jason Witten – TE Cowboys: Witten was targeted 6 times last week, and managed to catch just 2 of them. Overall this season he has been thrown to 19 times, with just 8 of them resulting in a catch. Until Witten gets over his manos de piedra (hands of stone in Spanish) problem, I want no part of him anywhere near my starting line-up.

Atlanta Falcons defense: The Falcons are currently ranked #4 in leagues, a surprise to me as I have focused more on their offense than their defense this season. But, as I laid out before, I think Cam I Am and the running game will set up the passing game enough to make this one a shoot-out. I would sit the Falcons defense and look to a defense like the Bengals (owned in 14.5 percent of leagues) or Cowboys (34.2 percent) to fill in this week.

Be sure to check back here on Sunday for last-minute fantasy injury updates.

Also, for more fantasy guidance, follow James on Twitter here.


Please Note:
The opinions, analysis and/or speculation expressed by The Finsiders Blog represent those of individual writers, and unless quoted or clearly labeled as such, do not represent the opinions, policies or desires of the Miami Dolphins organization, front office, coaches and executives. Writers' views are formulated independently from any inside information and/or conversation with Dolphins officials, including the coaches and scouts, unless otherwise noted.

Leave a Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.